RSS Feed
May 6

Number 1s of 2010 – 2 May 2010

Posted on Thursday, May 6, 2010 by Paul in Music

It’s election night, the night when people all across Britain stay up to two or three in the morning before it finally dawns on them that they won’t know for sure till next morning.  And so!  Let’s devote our time to something else instead.

Our new number 1 is the latest in the series of grime acts making a shameless bid for mainstream stardom.

This is “Good Times” by Roll Deep. (Non-embeddable YouTube version here.)

Roll Deep have been around for years, in various permutations.  They’re more of a collective than a band as such, but former members include Dizzee Rascal and Tinchy Stryder, both of whom made the crossover to the mainstream a while ago.  Of the current line-up, the best known is Wiley, who’s had several hits of his own dating back to 2004, the biggest being “Wearing My Rolex” (number 2 in 2008).

Roll Deep themselves have generally kept a slightly lower profile.  Their back catalogue ranges from minimalist grime includes credible but accessible hip-hop like “When I’m ‘Ere.”

For the most part, however, they’ve stayed under the chart radar.  The exception was in 2005, when “Avenue” made number 11 and “Shake A Leg” got to 24.  By 2005 standards, both singles were something of a bid for mainstream acceptance, with radio friendly samples and a bit of novelty value.  But they haven’t been seen in the charts since (despite releasing two albums since then).

“Good Times” obviously marks something of a departure for the group, since it’s a shameless bid for daytime radio.  I suspect there’s a degree of purist-baiting going on here.  Note how the opening seconds are terrifyingly reminiscent of “Heaven” by DJ Sammy.  Raise an eyebrow at a background vocal hook that’s suspiciously similar to “Come on Barbie, let’s go party.”  Ponder at the low-budget wedding reception look of the video.  And wonder at a vision of late-night hedonism that includes popping out for some “late night shopping on a Thursday.”

But it’s a good pop song, it really is.  It sounds nothing like Roll Deep – when I first heard it I actually double-checked that I’d downloaded the right track from Spotify – but it’s a good pop song.  It could be at the top for a while.

The other big surprise on this week’s chart is the appearance at number 29 of “She’s Always a Woman” by Billy Joel, a track from his 1977 album “The Stranger”.  In 1986 it was released as a double A-side single with “Just The Way You Are”, peaking at number 53.  But this is its first chart appearance.  Why?  Because a cover version is being used in this advert for the John Lewis department store, who would like you to know that your custom is welcome quite literally from cradle to grave.

The version in the advert is actually by Fyfe Dangerfield, the lead singer of the Guillemots.  But his version wasn’t available for most of the week, and so people have been downloading the original.  The Dangerfield version has been rush-released and will almost certainly chart in the top 20 on Sunday.

Also entering the chart this week:

Bring on the comments

  1. sam says:

    People have been forwarding around that john lewis commercial and posting it on facebook, so I’m not surprised it struck a nerve. I confess that, as the father of a young daughter, its emotional power is not insignificant, though of course rationally I know John Lewis just wants my money. I absolutely considered downloading this song after viewing it, and I’m obviously not the only one.

  2. Kid Zemo says:

    I would think that the market just about exhausted its supply of customers for “She’s Always a Woman” and that there wouldn’t be many left by the time the cover comes out.
    I also can’t imagine they’ll sell many downloads to those who couldn’t wait and bought the original. It’s not really different enough, is it? I think it’ll turn out to be a great lost opportunity, except to Billy Joel’s publisher.

  3. andrew says:

    Do you find the success of Glee odd?

  4. clay says:

    You know, when my wife and I went to Belfast a couple of years back, we heard country music… well, not everywhere, but in several places. The populace seemed to like it fine. (Snow Patrol; now *they* were everywhere.)

    N. Ireland is technically the same country, but I know it’s a different world than England (and, I would suppose, Scotland and Wales).

    Do these kind of regional differences show up on the charts?

  5. clay says:

    Oh, and speaking of elections, any thoughts? I seem to recall you (Paul) commenting on the election that brought Labour into power .

    (Yes, I’ve been reading you that long. We’re both old.)

  6. I Am Not A Robot’s actually a re-release; it came out originally near the beginning of the year just before Hollywood and the album. Why they’ve chosen to redo that single (which I do quite like) rather than the much catchier and radio-friendly Mowgli’s Road I don’t know.

  7. LiamK says:

    “…before it finally dawns on them that they won’t know for sure till next morning.”

    That’s worked out well, hasn’t it?

Leave a Reply