RSS Feed
Oct 9

Binary #1 annotations

Posted on Thursday, October 9, 2025 by Paul in Annotations

BINARY #1
Writer: Stephanie Phillips
Artist: Giada Beluiso
Colourist: Rachelle Rosenberg
Letterer: Travis Lanham
Editor: Annalise Bissa

COVER: Binary, now with added Phoenix emblem.

This is another “Age of Revelation” miniseries, and I’m covering it in this feature because it’s standing in for an ongoing title, Phoenix.

Binary is a former identity of Carol Danvers (Captain Marvel), which she used as a member of the Starjammers after gaining cosmic powers. The reference is supposed to be to binary stars (hence the two stars on her normal costume motif, but that’s replaced here by the Phoenix emblem). As Binary, she was part of the extended X-Men supporting cast. Obviously Carol has had plenty of solo books under the titles Ms Marvel and Captain Marvel, but this is the first book to appear under the name Binary.

PAGES 1-4. Hank and co try to kill Binary, and fail.

This is a flash forward to “five days from now”, and we’ll see in a bit what Hank is up to – suffice to say that his insinuations that Binary has done something to deserve assassination are misdirection.

Beverly, Massachusetts. This is the town where Carol grew up, and Carol tells us later that she came here by “instinct”. The energy dome in the sky is Binary’s powers keeping the X-virus at bay. The plants seem to be growing well enough, so apparently it doesn’t affect the skylight.

Phoenix. We’re told that Jean Grey has died, and that Carol is the new Phoenix. Carol has shown up as a guest star (rather than a supporting character) in the regular Phoenix title, but it’s not a stretch to think that Jean might suggest her as an acceptable host. We’re told in the next scene that Carol has been using her powers to defend Beverly from the X-virus for “almost ten years”. Since Age of Revelation is set ten years into the future, the implication is that Jean didn’t make it very far past the present day.

Of course, we’ve been told plenty of times in recent years that Jean is Phoenix. But none of those statements have ever attempted to retcon away the facts that Jean and Phoenix were separate for many years and that Phoenix has had other hosts. It does, however, raise the question of how far the Phoenix is still connected to Jean. We’ll come back to that.

PAGES 5-8. Carol addresses a town meeting.

The basic idea here is that Hank is turning the people of Beverly against Carol by playing to their paranoia. Carol has psychic powers, presumably from Phoenix. After being kept isolated from the X-virus for ten years, the people are getting paranoid about whether the whole thing is a scam to keep them under Carol’s thumb for some reason. Who’s to say they haven’t found a cure by now? Has anyone ever seen this Revelation guy trying to get in? (Evidently not, though we see later on that there are Babels hanging around outside the dome.) How can we know that even the original X-virus wasn’t a false memory? It’s not too difficult to imagine a story where this actually was the plot, so it’s not too much of a stretch.

How exactly this Boston suburb has sustained itself for so many years is left unclear, but Hank refers to Carol controlling what comes into the bubble. This suggests that someone outside the bubble is apparently helping to supply food, but why? Nor is it clear why Revelation hasn’t attacked the place, though we could reasonably conclude that if Phoenix wants to sit around and defend a subsurb until she gives up from exhaustion, letting her get on with it is probably a better strategy than picking a fight.

PAGES 9-12. Hank reports back to his employer.

Hank seems to be more interested in taking pleasure in his successes than whatever agenda his employer might have – and apparently expects that she’ll share his enthusiasm. He quietens down quickly once it’s clear that she’s interested in the bigger picture.

The employer remains anonymous in this issue, but she’s a redheaded woman in a black hood and cloak, and she seems to be able to summon up a sort of psychic serpent thing. The plan is to break Carol’s spirit, but quite why is unclear. When we see her clearly at the end of the issue, she sure looks like Jean Grey, though her costume suggests she’s more likely to be Jean’s clone Madelyne Pryor. AoR Madelyne has clearly lost control of Limbo at some point, since Magik was claiming her territory as a part of Limbo in Amazing X-Men #1.

Madelyne (or whoever) gives us some exposition about the Babels, the people who’ve been punished by Revelation by having thier capacity for language removed. She seems to compare their situation to having been restored to the garden of Eden, since that fits better with her serpent imagery. The idea seems to be that the serpent is somehow able to open a breach in the bubble and let the Babels in, I think – the art isn’t very clear on this sequence at all. At any rate, she’s clearly responsible somehow for letting the Babels in, and her ability to interfere with the Phoenix’s protective bubble would also tend to suggest some sort of connection with its power. Then again…

PAGES 13-15. Carol talks with the mayor.

According to Carol, the Phoenix Force also doesn’t want to be sitting here protecting Beverly. Presumably, the Phoenix doesn’t regard this as an appropriate function for a cosmic entity, and it has a point. This would dovetail to some extent with themes from Phoenix about whether Jean should be using her power as a goddess or from a human perspective. And it raises another possibility, which is that Hank’s employer is a manifestation of the Phoenix itself, trying to put a stop to this so that it can get back to doing appropriate cosmic things. Or maybe the Phoenix is simply willing to help her.

PAGES 16-20. Binary fights the Babels.

Since humans apparently can’t live in “this mutant land”, the Babels are mutants (albeit all human-presenting ones) with generic energy-blasting powers. In her narration, Binary delivers a monologue about the importance of protecting “those who can’t protect themselves” as she beats up the Babels. It doesn’t seem to have occurred to her that the Babels themselves might meet that description, and indeed Hank’s employer signals that (in her view) Carol is misreading the situation.

Bring on the comments

  1. Chris V says:

    Well, that plot just seems to trail off, based on this annotation.

    Madelyne seems to be struggling with her metaphor. Prior to the Tower of Babel (hence in the Garden of Eden), all humans could apparently understand each other. After the Tower of Babel, humans speaking a single language were unable to understand the language of humans speaking other languages. It would be a poor analogy, regardless. As the metaphor Madelyne presents, it doesn’t work.

  2. MasterMahan says:

    Brand new Phoenix, same old poorly considered high concepts. This clearly meant as a covid and conspiracy analogy, but it falls apart with the slightest consideration.

    There’s really no way to safely move people outside the Revelation lands? They’re presumably sterilizing the supplies they’re bringing in, but there’s no cleanroom technology? Bringing in enough supplies for thousands of people for nearly a decade is easier than moving them? They really can’t establish outside communication?

    The mayor mentions her term ended ages ago, so apparently they’ve just abandoned democracy? Carol Danvers won’t let anyone leave, even though some people clearly want to risk the virus? Yeah, she is a dictator. A benign dictator, but still a dictator.

    *sigh* Well, at least it’s in-character for Carol.

  3. Michael says:

    @MasterMahan- Yeah, the limitations on Carol’s powers seem contrived to create the moral dilemma. She can create a telekinetic dome around the town to protect them from the virus but she can’t just create a giant telekinetic airplane or whatever, have them all get on and then fly them to safety in Canada?
    “Presumably, the Phoenix doesn’t regard this as an appropriate function for a cosmic entity, and it has a point.”
    I think the idea is that the Phoenix wants to stop Revelation and the X-Virus from destroying the world but Carol is letting the rest of the world- and the people Jean cared for- suffer just to protect the people of Beverly.
    I assumed that Carol was gathering the supplies herself. Although it’s not clear where she would get enough supplies for thousands of people.
    Regarding communication with the outside world. if Carol has Jean’s telepathy. you’d think that she would be able to contact the President of the remaining United States and have him decide what to do with the town.

  4. Joe says:

    The art of Carol as Binary is pretty good. That alone is worth a look, if not the story.

  5. Moo says:

    “The reference is supposed to be to binary stars (hence the two stars on her normal costume motif, but that’s replaced here by the Phoenix emblem).”

    Ah. So, her costume is non-binary now.

  6. Taibak says:

    I used to work in Beverly and grew up near there. Reading about this sounds more than a little bizarre to me.

  7. Oldie says:

    This sounds a bit like the inverse of WandaVision. In both, a powerful woman is keeping a small town in a reality bubble.

  8. CoffeeFilter says:

    If Carol has the power of the Phoenix why is she going toe to toe with the Babels instead of just Cosmic Powering them back outside of the bubble?

Leave a Reply