The X-Axis – 18 November 2026
DNX #5. (Annotations here.) Final issue of the series, and it’s the big showdown between Cyclops and the Chairman. Which is a little odd when you come to think of it, because you might have expected the other Beast to play a role in this story. But no, it’s basically an issue of Scott and Hank fighting, and Scott sacrificing himself to stop Hank from destroying the town. Federico Vientini is working overtime here to make a fight between Cyclops and the Beast look epic, and mostly gets away with it, though it gets a bit confused at times – the best moments of art are actually in the flashbacks. I appreciate keeping the focus on the characters rather than going for epic scale, even if it’s another reason why this might have played out better as an arc in X-Men (and it certainly didn’t need the Fantastic Four). And there’s an intriguing angle here in the idea that of all the Silver Age X-Men, Hank was the one who started off most integrated into normal human society, and who seems to have been damaged the most by being essentially separated from it. Taking Scott off the board seems like a good direction for the series too, given how central he’s been to the whole team dynamic, and I like the fact that they’re not even going through the motions of trying to convince the readers that he’s really dead; what matters for this story is that the X-Men believe it, not that we do. The whole virus plot feels a bit scrappy to me, though – we’re apparently just meant to take it that the FF’s anti-virus thing will work, even though it was designed for the original X-virus, and Juniper’s version is different. Juniper itself feels like it gets brushed aside in the scramble to trail a Phoenix story, too. Hopefully they’ll get proper follow-up somewhere else.
MIDNIGHT X-MEN #2. By Jonathan Hickman, Matteo Della Fonte, Arthur Hesli & Cory Petit. So, no, I’m not going to do regular annotations for this series. Not because it isn’t good, but because I just don’t have the time. After the first issue of Midnight X-Men set up the present day status quo of an uneasy truce between mutants, vampires and empyres, this issue goes back ten years to explain what happened to the X-Men. After an introductory monologue by Dracula about his history, which suggests that things like the Crusades and the Black Death were all just a cover for the Church to go after innocent vampires, we have Storm apparently becoming a vampire by choice, and Cyclops being lured in time and again to bring team after team of X-Men to try and rescue her, with predictably disastrous results. The underlying idea here is that this is Scott and Jean’s relationship after she’s been corrupted by both the Phoenix and the vampires, since the Phoenix is pretty relaxed about the undead, really.
That’s a strong idea and very effectively done, with Della Fonte’s artwork giving us some lovely scenes in pitch black. The issue does lean a little more heavily than the first on riffing on continuity – we’re playing off the Storm/Dracula thing from X-Men Annual #6, but more to the point, the whole story is Cyclops endlessly replaying a version of Giant-Size X-Men #1 by making repeated doomed efforts to rescue his team, which are really just delivering more vampires to his beloved. I suppose you don’t really need to get that reference, and it’s not like it’s an obscure piece of continuity, but I’m more interested in seeing Hickman build this world.
TOMB OF APOCALYPSE #4. By Ashley Allen, Domenico Carbone, Fer Sifuentes-Sujo & Joe Sabino. This really isn’t doing it for me. And in this issue, it’s not even to do with the resetting of Apocalypse’s character, since he’s basically not in the issue. It’s just that this whole issue is a rather confusing fight scene. What we’re getting at, I suppose, is to dig up the old thing of Apocalypse turning people into his Horsemen, and to have the rejected Rictor try to make himself into a Horseman whether Apocalypse really wants him to or not. That’s kind of interesting, and I don’t mind following up on Rictor’s story, particularly since his devotion to Apocalypse was very much left open-ended, and becomes odd in a world where he’s being reverted to villain status. I’m frankly less interested in seeing Shatterstar take the bullet for him, though, and the chaotic art here isn’t exactly well placed to sell emotion. And all of this seems like a very odd direction for a story that started off based around Jubilee – why didn’t we just do this as a Rictor and Shatterstar plot?
X-ORCISTS #1. By Ashley Allen, Germán Peralta, Marte Gracia & Travis Lanham. First issue of a five-issue miniseries, and this is rather more like it. Despite the title, it’s basically another arc of Allen’s Magik run, with Juggernaut and Madelyne Pryor as the guests. Neither of them is exactly a forced inclusion, since Maddie is the current ruler of Limbo, and Juggernaut has been linked with Magik over in X-Men for a while. Admittedly, the first issue is basically our heroes having a misunderstanding fight, then teaming up to deal with an escaped demon from Limbo, and maybe it could have got to the point a bit quicker. But the point it’s setting up is that this thing seems to be a Limbo denizen that neither Illyana nor Maddie has ever heard of, which Shouldn’t Be A Thing. That’s a more intriguing than the fight itself. And we’ve got some great artwork here, with the wreckage of the fairground given weird hellish lighting even though it’s meant to be in the real world, and a nicely cartoonish Juggernaut amidst it all. He’s a big punchy guy, after all. A decent start.
GAMBIT: WANTED #4. By Chris Claremont, Robert Gill, Bryan Valenza & Ariana Maher. I think I’m going to have to go back and re-read Claremont’s previous Gambit miniseries – from four years ago now – because it feels like I’m meant to have that story much more clearly in my mind than I do. To be honest, I don’t really remember very much about it at all, but at this point I’ll wait for the mini to actually finish and read them back to back. In the meantime, this is the fight issue, and it’s very Claremont, and the art is pretty good, but I’m kind of lost and I need to set aside some time to remind myself what the hell is going on. Which I don’t have today, I’m afraid.
X-MEN: INCURSIONS #1. By Alek Paknadel, Jim Towe, Fer Sifuentes-Sujo & Clayton Cowles. This is the first of several one-shots revisiting the “incursions” idea from the run-up to Jonathan Hickman’s Secret Wars back in 2015, in which two timelines collide and only one can survive, all of which ultimately leads to Battleworld as the remains of the universe. As a premise, this is decidedly unenticing – Marvel has done an awful lot of these continuity implant nostalgia things, and I’m quite relieved to see that the upcoming solicitations seem to be dialling back on them. The incursions seem especially unsuited to any stories beyond just randomly colliding some continuities for the hell of it, and nothing in the solicitations (which have different creative teams on every issue) suggests that there’s any through line here. All that being said… this was better than I expected. It’s Days of Future Past and House of M, and it isn’t really a fight between the two worlds at all – well, the Sentinels duly fly up to the House of M world in a doomed attempt to wipe out a planet of mutants, but that’s about it. Instead, it’s Kate Pryde being given a tour of the House of M world and, if anything, being left even more depressed by the thought that such a world was apparently possible – what does that say about her world’s X-Men, if they would up with Sentinel concentration camps instead? There’s something in that, but it doesn’t feel essential.

Paul> X-ORCISTS #1. By Ashley Allen, Germán Peralta, Marte Gracia & Travis Lanham. First issue of a five-issue miniseries, and this is rather more like it.
It was changed to an ongoing a while back. (For some reason, they announced the upgrade at a con with a skit involving Iman Vellani demanding it from the crowd.)
So the Astonishing team gets turned into horror monster fodder for the second time in as many months! Coincidence?
But using Astonishing Cyclops was a stroke of genius here, considering the whole Jean fakeout back then. If any Scott would fall this far, it was that one.
@K
Technically, it was his San Francisco costume from a while later (they revised all the costumes at that point to have Xs on their left chests, and added some extra piping to Cyclops’ left shoulder while they were at it).
Quick thoughts:
Midnight X-Men very swiftly goes into some deep dive obscure territory with a patented Hickman Infographic detailing the fates of the first few waves of Cyclops’s teams. I mean… Match? Greymalkin? UMBRA? (I had to look him up. A several appearance wonder and crowd-filler from the pre-Decimation days…) Velocidad? X-Men history is a thorough jumble here, isn’t it?
Tomb of Apocalypse is several kinds of nonsense. Shatterstar becoming Starfall with the Apocalypse Horseman Upgrade Package, which somehow involves healing/restoring Rictor’s arm, wristband and all… I wonder if this is supposed to be a permanent upgrade or forgotten as soon as this is over. At least Jubilee is safe, apart from the art continuing to depict her as generously busty…
X-Men Incursions was… interesting. It felt like they were trying to emulate Claremont but falling short. Having Doctor Strange show up in his pre-Secret Wars role just to give Kate Pryde a tour of House of M before depositing her in that reality? Like, will this ever be referenced again? Since House of M gets destroyed anyway when the multiverse collapses. I assume it gets restored in Reality 8 with so many other alternates, so is Kate in House of M, or returned to DoFP? And what was up with adding Carol of all people, since she literally never played a role of any note in that story? (And then killing her off rather horribly…)
These Incursion one-shots remind me of the Earth-D spotlight DC did, where we knew no one would survive because the larger storyline pretty much determined everyones’ fates. Yeah, here’s these realities you know–too bad they all get destroyed and turned into Battleworld, if lucky.
Gambit: Wanted… Claremont doing what Claremont does. I literally forgot he’d done another Gambit series.
X-Orcists: a series created simply because someone desperately wanted to use the title. But it’s entertaining enough. I still dislike Illyana’s look and giant sword, even though she’s been using it for… god, how long? Since 2013? Oof. There’s still something to be said for the original Soulsword’s sleekness. Anyway, I’m down for exploring Limbo’s deep weirdness.
A gay couple headlining a Marvel book, Paul? Such ideas you have! Wiccan and Hulkling can’t even get equal billing these days
Curiously, Marvel never seems to have put anything in writing confirming X-ORCISTS as an ongoing, and Amazon still lists it as a five-issue miniseries. At any rate, I’m not planning to do annotations for it, because I don’t have time to do the whole line and this doesn’t feel like a book that really needs them. (If anything, I’m considering dropping WOLVERINE from the annotations.)
Re: X-Orcists 1:
It’s interesting in that when Maddie’s arguing that they need to use lethal force against the demon even if the hosts dies, she tells Juggernaut that the Alaskan X-Men are trying to make themselves into something they’re not. She seemed to be saying that Scott’s X-Men wouldn’t kill a possessed person who was attacking others. I’m not sure that MacKay’s Scott wouldn’t use lethal force against someone who was under mind control if necessary. In fact, the X-Men under Claremont seemed to go back and forth about whether it was ethical to kill a possessed person to stop them from endangering others. Alex nearly killed Lorna when she was possessed by Malice, then they went back and forth on the ethics of killing innocent people possessed by the Brood, then Betsy suggested killing Lorna AGAIN when she was possessed by Malice and Alex said no., etc.
It’s nice to see Selene again. I guess her cult is trying to awaken her from the illusion that Dani and Roberto trapped her in.
So this series features Selene the Black Queen of the Hellfire Club against Madelyne Pryor the Goblin Queen. Illyana the former Queen of Limbo and … Juggernaut? One of the things is not like the others, one of these things does not belong.
Juggernaut works well. He’s a giant force of destruction, empowered by an otherworld/extra-dimensional being. He’s the physical balance to all the magic-users involved, and he can punch demons really hard.
Plus, on a thematic level, he makes for an interesting contrast to Illyana teaming up with Piotr in the previous mini.
TOM> I assume it gets restored in Reality 8 with so many other alternates, so is Kate in House of M, or returned to DoFP?
If she stays in HoM, either it gets reset or it’s alternate-of-an-alternate scenario; because she’s destined to become Widget.
Michael> It’s nice to see Selene again. I guess her cult is trying to awaken her from the illusion that Dani and Roberto trapped her in.
Eh, when was that?
The Brood didn’t just possess people, as the host would eventually gestate a new parasite which would kill the host, and there wasn’t any way to stop the parasitic infection. I’d say the Brood are a different issue. Xavier had to be killed and replaced with a clone body to house his consciousness. Unless the X-Men are going to clone anyone infected or find some handy Acanti, the Brood’s eggs are a death sentence.
Another interesting thing about X-Orcists 1- Maddie tells the sisters that she always wanted a sister. The obvious reference is to Jean but in X-Men 173, when Maddie meets Kitty, she thinks that she always wanted a sister like her.
@SamityOrMadness- It happened in X-Men Unlimited Infinity Comic 142.