RSS Feed
Oct 4

The X-Axis – 4 October 2026

Posted on Sunday, October 4, 2026 by Paul in x-axis

DNX #2. (Annotations here.) This is the busiest week we’ve had in ages. Three ongoing titles, one event mini, one event tie-in, two miniseries and an out of continuity mini that seems worth a look anyway. So yes, we’re going to take some of this fairly quickly.

DNX is going for the now hallowed Marvel crossover format where the main story clearly belongs in Title A, but for some reason it’s taking place in Miniseries B while Title A does character spotlights in the margins. I don’t really get the thinking, but if doesn’t really matter as long as you’re willing to think of this issue as X-Men #37.5. The first two issues of DNX basically consist of the X-Men storming 3K’s Mothership and failing to stop the release of the virus, while Hank and Reed discuss how they’re going to retrieve the message from Magneto’s DNA. And all of that is pretty much how you’d expect it to play out, the only real twist being the misdirection about the release site – it feels like we should probably have got to this point by the end of issue #1, if you’re going to make it a separate miniseries. Then again, if these were just issues of X-Men, I probably wouldn’t be saying that, would I?

In itself, it’s just a fun action story – which at least tends to suggest that the rest of this event isn’t going to be grim body horror, and I guess that’s a nice signal to have. But what continues to elevate it for me is the Chairman, utterly convinced that this was a good plan despite belatedly figuring out that hiring a group of villains who don’t trust him was a bad idea, and making his best effort to convince Scott that they ought to be on the same side really. It’s essentially the same thing we were doing in Krakoa, but I do like the shift of emphasis from “ends justify the means” to “what do you mean, justify?”

X-MEN #38. (Annotations here.) Meanwhile, over in the character spotlight tie-in, we have Magneto arguing with either a hallucination of Professor X or the real Professor X, delete according to taste. The basic point here is that losing control of his powers goes to the root of Magneto’s identity, which makes sense – not only is it essential to him that he’s a mutant, it’s essential to him that he’s a powerful mutant. So while Krakoa has him come round to the idea of defending all of the oppressed and marginalised, there’s a limit to how far he actually identifies with the idea of being one of them. On one level this is just a straightforward story about Magneto rediscovering his urge to live, but I do like the way that Magneto shrugs off all of the arguments about what a contribution he’s been able to make to the series without his powers – it’s only when he’s given a way of thinking about his situation as a sign of how terribly important he is that he really seems able to embrace it as Magneto-like. That’s a nice take on the character which plays up his ego without making him a villain. And for a story much of which is two people talking in a darkened room, it manages to stay quite visual into the bargain.

FANTASTIC FOUR #17. By Ryan North, Vincenzo Carratù, Edgar Delgado & Joe Caramagna. Ryan North’s Fantastic Four is a great series, but not one that you might expect to lend itself to participating in crossovers. What it does well is high concept, self-contained stories where the FF (or one of them) encounters some bizarre new phenomenon or solves some new mystery. Still, it has done a few tie-ins and North has made it work, largely by prioritising what the book does well over the crossover plot. And that’s pretty much what we have here – it’s an issue of an amnesiac FF trying to work out who they are and what they’re doing, only for us to find out at the end that this is a Fantastic Voyage deal inside Magneto’s body, which has evidently gone wrong. That’s your tie-in, and no doubt it will advance the wider plot in that way, but principally this is an FF amnesia story. How that’ll play with X-Men readers who are only buying this for the crossover, I’m not sure, but it certainly plays to the strengths of Fantastic Four, even if it does raise awkward questions of the “doesn’t this guy have bodily fluids” variety. Ignore the crossover aspects and it’s simply a good issue of FF.

UNCANNY X-MEN #38. (Annotations here.) This is the final part of “Wild Ride”, which means Gambit gets his exorcism, and the X-Men back in New Orleans take down some mutant traffickers. There are some interesting ideas here, but the execution is choppy. So the idea that the X-Men under M are up for killing the mutant who’s helping the traffickers is kind of interesting, but feels like something Nightcrawler ought to have something to say about – and what was the point of tying the compound to the Word of Strength cult in the previous issue, if it’s just about the money? Plus, the crowd of evil rich people only register as present at all at the last moment – their presence just isn’t really established before that.

The exorcism thread works better – the Iron Cathedral is a nice visual, complete with the unexplained red sky, and the iconography of Christian magic seems a lot more unfamiliar and offputting than the usual trappings of Marvel magic. There are some confused signals, though, in terms of playing up the idea that mutants were the victims of persecution by witchfinders in the past, at the same time as showing exorcism as the solution Gambit needs. That tension is intriguing – in the Marvel Universe, after all, the witchfinders had rather more of a point – but it doesn’t feel like the story takes it anywhere. The emotional hook of this story is basically that Rogue and Gambit’s love conquers all, and that’s fine, but Gabriel and Repent feel underused, and the demon itself is never especially interesting.

X-MEN UNITED #7. (Annotations here.) It’s been quite a break from the previous issue, and I’ll give it this – it’s probably the best art we’ve had on X-Men United to date. Ruarí Coleman’s work here has some clarity and energy to it. As for the story, for some reason we’re going on a detour from the Shadow King storyline to helping Blade rescue his daughter from a mutant. Leave aside that this finally picks up on the dangling plot thread from when Justina LaGuardia was introduced in a back-up strip in Giant-Size X-Men; she only shows up at the end of the issue, so we’ll see more of her next time. It just feels like a weird change of direction in the story, despite some heroically unconvincing attempts to persuade me that, why, these two things must be related! I’m not averse to seeing Wither again, but making him a vampire doesn’t seem especially interesting – he already had a thing where he had a hunger to use his decay powers, so what’s the practical difference? And Blade… I’ve never found Blade interesting, so I’m maybe not the audience for this anyway. Generally, there’s a lack of focus in X-Men United, which is trying to juggle too many characters and too many plot threads and doesn’t need another.

TOMB OF APOCALYPSE #2. By Ashley Allen, Domenico Carbone, Fer Sifuentes-Sujo & Joe Sabino. Hmm, this seems to be mostly just Jubilee, Rictor, Shatterstar and Wolverine making their way through a tomb full of traps and things. That’s not a plot that does much for me. Still, it looks nice – that cliffhanger with the giant robot thing is lovely. And it’s Ashley Allen, which means there are at least some interesting character points. Much of this issue is really about following up on how Rictor feels after his plotline as Apocalypse’s protégé ended with him being left behind on Earth. Shatterstar seems to have shown up for this story mainly to let Rictor get it out of his system, and that’s an angle that has some legs to it. I’m much less sure about the way we’re now acting as though nobody ever trusted Apocalypse on Krakoa – this isn’t how I remember Jubilee’s attitude in Excalibur, and it doesn’t ring true for me.

GAMBIT: WANTED #3. By Chris Claremont, Robert Gill, Bryan Valenza & Ariana Maher. This is the flashback mini from around the time of Gambit’s debut. It’s a mid-series instalment which is basically a well-drawn extended chase scene, mostly from the perspective of a supporting character, since Gambit himself is mind-controlled Honestly, I don’t get why he stops being mind-controlled. Maybe it’ll make more sense when I re-read the whole thing at the end.

ALIEN VS X-MEN #1. By Kieron Gillen, Geraldo Borges, Andrew Dalhouse & Travis Lanham. I don’t normally do the out-of-continuity stories, but what the heck. This is an odd IP crossover, not because the two properties can’t fit together, but because we already know they do – Alien is an obvious inspiration for the Brood, as well as for X-Men #143 (the one where an N’Garai demon chases Kitty through the school). So what do you actually do with Real, Officially Licensed Alien vs X-Men? Well, you’re not going for intellectual depth. But you can take advantage of the fact that it’s an out of continuity X-Men, which means you can tease transforming or killing characters without an obvious reset button hanging over everything. And you can do Storm as Ripley. It’s a romp, really, but it pulls that off nicely without being just a string of reference points.

The back-up strip by Chris Claremont and Dave Messina is a completely different out-of-continuity continuity, with Kitty taken from circa Mekanix and the Brood enlisting her to save the X-Men from the aliens. It’s mostly what you’d expect, but the idea of a Brood Queen ghost showing up as Kitty’s guardian angel spirit is genuinely cute.

Bring on the comments

  1. Chris V says:

    Did three issues of Uncanny X-Men ship in September, or am I wrong?

    Hmm…This alternate universe where the X-Men meet the Xenomorphs could be the WildStorm Universe, as the WildCATs & Aliens one-shot was actually in-continuity for WildStorm.

  2. The Other Michael says:

    The X-Men vs Aliens was genuinely odd. The team being the Whedon-era, only with the addition of latecomers like Hope, and bald Storm. And starting by fighting Orbis Stellaris. And killing off some major X-Men right off the bat before leaning into lesser characters and a time travel kill squad. This is utter lunacy and I’m wondering where it will go.

    I’m still mad about Aliens vs WildC.A.T.s because of how Ellis used it as an excuse to kill off so many Stormwatch characters offscreen to lay the foundation for The Authority. It was devastating for those of us who’d come to like those characters in his run… and of course they all came back eventually because comics.

  3. Krzysiek Ceran says:

    Brevoort should give Ashley Allen a main team ongoing at this point. It might suck, but she earned the chance to fail at it. (This might sound negative – I like her x-books a lot, but she’s still new; I think the Magik ongoing & assorted minis is the biggest thing she wrote so far in terms of scope).

    Musings on this week:
    Uncanny – well, M kills people sometimes. I’m not sure if it’s habitual (though during Krakoa it seems everybody dabbled in it – I’m pretty sure she shreds some people in House of X), but it’s happened before.

    I’m basically on board with the b-plot, though there are nits to pick, as ever with this volume. ‘You were always kind to me’ – when? Nightcrawler missed the Silver Age, Pietro was far away from x-books in the Bronze Age, and Kurt was in Excalibur in the 90s. When did he ever have a chance to be kind to Pietro? In the last three days, perhaps?

    But the exorcism plot is at once too contrived and blandly straightforward. They need an exorcism. They do the exorcism. End of story. Rogue’s pregnant, perhaps, but – sorry, arc over, possibly stay tuned, true believers, maybe.

    AvX – the name itself is a cute gag. From the solicits, I was expecting it to be strictly about the Astonishing team, so more fool me. It’s funny, I don’t think of Gillen as a ‘it’s my book, I’m bringing my toys’ kind of writer, but this issue has Beast namedrop Brand and SWORD, Hope gets many lines (and is in the book at all – it’s not like she was ever a pivotal member of the X-Men… Maybe the Extinction Team, but that was, again, Gillen), we open on a Sinister… I was almost looking out for Kid Loki (not really, but you get my meaning).

  4. Michael says:

    Re: Fantastic Four 17- The FF story featured one of the more annoying amnesia tropes- when someone in a fictional universe gets amnesia, they remember the basic background information everyone in real life knows but forget the basic background information everyone in the fictional universe knows. For example. suppose Alice is a scantily-clad mutant superheroine in the Marvel Universe and she loses her memory. If someone suggests she’s a stripper, she’ll know what a stripper is but if someone suggests she’s a mutant, she’ll be like “What’s a mutant?”, even though everyone in the Marvel Universe knows what mutants are.
    In this case, the FF seem to know what cults, flamethrowers and doctors are but when Reed and Sue see Ben they panic, even though disfigured but harmless mutants are common in the Marvel Universe. Even after they realize he’s harmless, they don’t wonder if he’s a mutant.
    I get that Johnny was amnesiac but I’m not sure I like him flaming on when he accidentally says flame on. He’s not Billy Batson or Black Adam who automatically transform when they say Shazam.

  5. Michael says:

    Re: Tomb of Apocalypse 2- I think the real problem is Tina Howard and Hickman. All of a sudden, when House of X came out, everyone trusted Apocalypse and Rictor was fanatically devoted to Apocalypse. That made no sense for Rictor- the entire point of his character was that he came from a family of arms dealers and rejected it, so his accepting Apocalypse’s ideology made no sense. (And let’s not forget that his father was killed by someone raised by an alternate future version of Apocalypse.) Allen seems to be trying to salvage Rictor’s character.

  6. Michael says:

    In other news, Bleeding Cool’s Weekly Bestseller List is out. Aliens vs. X-Men 1 came in 3rd. DNX 2 came in 4th. X-Men 38 came in 6th. Fantastic Four 17 came in 8th. Uncanny X-Men 36 came in 9th. X-Men United 7, Tomb of Apocalypse 2 and Gambit: Wanted 3 didn’t make the top, um, 11.
    In non X-books, Amazing Spider-Man 1000 came in 1st- it appears to have done quite well. Amazing Venom 1 came in 2nd- I know it was a number 1 but it’s amazing how Boomerang in a symbiote outsold MJ in a symbiote this week.

  7. Chris V says:

    It’s also kind of amazing that fans would rather read an out of continuity story featuring a movie tie-in franchise than the big X-event of the year.

  8. Michael says:

    Some of the X-characters appear in Queen in Black this week. The finale seemed rushed- Flash. Dylan and Toxin disappear completely from the story.
    MJ told the world her real name when she addressed the world. Does that mean everyone knows that MJ was Venom or did they forget when Venomworld fell apart?
    The biggest problem was that Sleeper’s plan seemed completely contrived. Sleeper’s not supposed to be precognitive, right? But its plan to steal Knull’s throne depended on Reed conducting a particular experiment using Dylan and MJ to stop Knull, the experiment going wrong because no one told Reed that Egnarac was magical and Venom forming a symbiosis with the entire world. There’s no way Sleeper could have predicted all that. This is what TV Tropes refers to as a Gambit Roulette.

  9. Michael says:

    In non X-book news, the main story in Amazing Spider-Man 1000 was horrible. I can’t believe anyone thought this was a good idea for a villain for Amazing Spider-Man’s 1000th issue? Aunt May’s and Uncle Ben’s long lost son turns out to be a supervillain with the power to erase memories? I mean, I guess you can sort of imagine the thinking behind this. Maybe Cormac is what Peter would have been if he hadn’t been raised by Uncle Ben and Aunt May. Peter is obsessed with responsibility- Cormac has the ability to make people forget when he does things that are wrong. But at some point, you would think someone would point out what a lame idea this is.

  10. Michael says:

    Also this week, Sorcerer Supreme 10 is out. This is the final issue of the series and the final issue of Steve Orlando’s Scarlet Witch run. Marvel finally decided to stop relaunching the Scarlet Witch series with Orlando as writer every time a series failed. I guess Orlando had blackmail material on Cebluski but not Wacker. 🙂
    Seriously, I’m nor sure why Marvel kept relaunching the Scarlet Witch series with Orlando instead of finding a new writer. Orlando seemed surprised that he was finally let go- there was a scene with what might have happened had Wanda remained Sorcerer Supreme that seemed to be showing plots Orlando had in mind.
    So as of Sorcerer Supreme 10, Wanda is no longer Sorcerer Supreme. And as of Dr. Strange 10. Strange is returning to Earth. So it looks like Strange will be Sorcerer Supreme again soon.

  11. Chris V says:

    Amazing Spider-Man #1000 should have been the return of the mermaid Uncle Ben and Aunt May adopted prior to Amazing Spider-Man #1. That’s the only story big enough to warrant the hype around issue #1000.

  12. The Other Michael says:

    “Re: Fantastic Four 17- The FF story featured one of the more annoying amnesia tropes- when someone in a fictional universe gets amnesia, they remember the basic background information everyone in real life knows but forget the basic background information everyone in the fictional universe knows.”

    At least in this case, it was artifically-induced amnesia due to yet more creative use of Sue’s powers, so we can maybe assume a lot of their subconscious still leaked through. Ben instinctively picking up the name Johnny, Johnny instinctively linking his powers to his catchphrase, that sort of thing. I mean, it’s comics and it’s Ryan North’s unique take on the team, we just gotta roll with it.

    Wanda’s tenure as Sorcerer Supreme was indeed surprisingly short. I guess the pressure was on to restore the status quo since this wrapped up simultaneously with Stephen’s return to Midgard/Earth, and presumably his abdication of the SS of Asgard role which he never truly wanted anyway except to fight Doom.

    (And trying to tie in Doctor Strange of Asgard during the period when Earth is still cut off from the other Nine Realms just highlights how awkward the situation is with Thor dead… I’m kind of impressed they actually did the whole Queen in Black event starring Hela and Tyr during this time. More power to Ewing for managing to make it all work.)

  13. Si says:

    I think the similarity between brood and Alien are overstated. They both lay eggs in people, and their faces are a bit alike. But the brood story came out in 1982, when there was only one Alien movie. That movie had a single man-shaped alien doing the slasher flick deal. There’s no doubt a good chunk of “homage” there, but the skittering hordes, the queen, the dread of knowing one is infected, that was all from the sequel, which came out years after the X-Men story. It almost makes you wonder if the inspiration actually flowed the other way.

    Of course, there might have already been a mythos behind the movie, that was shared in magazines and whatnot. I don’t care enough to dig that deep.

  14. Chris V says:

    Well, Claremont and Byrne had already homaged the original Alien movie with the N’Garai Christmas issue, featuring a demonic looking being (an actual demon, mind, not just “outer space is Hell”) straight from Giger and Kitty in the role of Ripley.

    No, I’m pretty sure there was no mythos established around the Alien movie until after Aliens, as most expected that Ridley Scott’s Alien would be a standalone movie. Some people knew about some background details that Scott got rid of with the final product, but Scott never envisioned a queen alien.
    I’ve heard the argument that the influence between the Brood and Aliens didn’t really go either way, with the only logical follow-up to Alien was that there was an entire species of them running around on a planet. The fact that Claremont came up with a Brood Queen prior to Aliens does sort of make you wonder. It is known that James Cameron was a comic book fan.

    The original “Alien” (before the term Xenomorph existed) wasn’t even really insectoid. It was more biomechanical, reptilian, slightly insectoid, very Lovecraftian. The reproduction cycle being parasitism was the aspect that pointed most to “insect”. Scott’s original idea wasn’t to have the “Alien” able to implant an egg in a host species. It was to actually turn its victims into its eggs, with the remaining flesh of the human/animal serving as a food source for the young. The special effects weren’t there yet to make it look believable, so Scott dropped that idea and decided that a species that could turn a male into a pregnant host worked.

  15. MasterMahan says:

    If Marvel’s going to introduce a supervillain who’s May and Ben’s secret kid, they could at least have called him Trouble.

  16. Luis Dantas says:

    “Amazing Venom #1” is in second place?

    Hard to explain. Was it presented as a tie-in to Queen in Black or something?

    In any case, I doubt that can be made to last unless some sort of very inspired pitch for using that odd status quo is presented somewhere. Not very likely.

    As for Wanda and Steve Orlando, I assume that it was a matter of giving what was perceived as an interesting take a chance to build a readership.

  17. Luis Dantas says:

    As for Tomb of Apocalypse… it is doing a superb job at presenting Jubilee as sexy and dynamic, I suppose.

    I can see that it also wants to explore Rictor’s feelings about the fallout of Krakoa and how they may impact his relationship with Shatterstar, but I don’t think it is doing a very good job at it. It is all in-your-face and presented while they are fighting for their lives to boot.

    Incidentally, is it just coincidence that all of a sudden Rictor, Shatterstar and Jubilee are starring in multiple books at once?

  18. Alastair says:

    Unlimited is closing and moving to a new Webtoon app.

    Its top tier Ultimate will be 30days from release putting it inline with DC infinite ultra.

  19. Taibak says:

    @Krzysiek: If it’s any consolation, Quicksilver was part of an Excalibur/West Coast Avengers team up in Excalibur #37 – 39. Problem is, if I remember right, Nightcrawler spent most of his time speaking high school German while teaming up with the Scarlet Witch.

  20. Taibak says:

    @Luis: If that’s indeed the case with the Scarlet Witch, more power to them. That’s the sort of thing Marvel should be doing more of.

  21. Alastair says:

    I’m not sure why Marvel thought the the Chasm version of Ben riley, was such a good idea we need a memory holed May. At least they can put her memories in the mind a genetically modified actress, so they have a back door if they ever decide to kill her, for a much better anniversary issue.

    Strange and Wanda were always going be rest ahead of Doomsday for synergy reasons.

  22. wwk5d says:

    “Scott’s original idea wasn’t to have the “Alien” able to implant an egg in a host species. It was to actually turn its victims into its eggs, with the remaining flesh of the human/animal serving as a food source for the young. The special effects weren’t there yet to make it look believable, so Scott dropped that idea and decided that a species that could turn a male into a pregnant host worked.”

    He didn’t drop it. A scene was filmed depicting that, but it was deleted from the movie.

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=dS5MtzrW1vU&pp=ygUaYWxpZW4gZGVsZXRlZCBzY2VuZSBkYWxsYXM%3D

  23. Michaael says:

    @Taibak- The problem with the Scarlet Witch series was this- Marvel would put out a series by Orlando with the Scarlet Witch in them, it would fail, they would relaunch it, there would be a temporary bump in sales due to a new number 1, it would be cancelled again, it would be relaunched again, etc. It was artificially prolonging a series instead of finding a new writer who could maybe make the series actually work.
    @Alastair- I doubt May’s memory loss is going to last long. Maybe a few months at most.
    Wanda might be in limbo for a little while but I doubt that Marvel would go to all the trouble of bringing Strange back from Asgard unless they were planning on having him resume the role of Sorcerer Supreme soon.
    My guess is that Odin will become the new Sorcerer Supreme of Asgard after Amora is defeated, since he keeps insisting that he doesn’t want the throne back.

  24. Michael says:

    Hickman revealed that the Ultimate Unverse wasn’t originally supposed to end after two years- the plan was for other writers to take over after the original writers (except for Camp) left. We’ve heard versions of this story before but Hickman explained that the writers were all told around issue 12 or 13 of their books that the books would be ending after two years and they had to adjust their plots to wrap up the books.
    I’m surprised Marvel cancelled their best selling line and I’m surprised how early the decision was made. Judging from what Hickman said, the decision was made before anyone knew how well the Absolute line would sell. And no one knew how badly Brevoort would screw up the X-Books at that point. But why would Marvel cancel its best-selling line?
    In other news, Betsy will be using a telekinetic sword in Maximum X-Men. So Betsy will be using a telekinetic sword from now on and Kwannon will be using a telepathic knife. I wonder if that will work.

  25. Adam says:

    Maybe AVX outsold the other books because of Gillen’s name. It’s the only reason I bought it, anyway.

    And rightly so. The whole issue’s a blast.

  26. Andrew says:

    Things do feel chaotic and directionless at Marvel at the moment.

    The X-book line is all over the shop and pumping out an insane amount of books while the whole Imperial event flamed out last year and now this Midnight thing is coming up in what feels to be a huge reaction to the Absolute line.

  27. Diana says:

    @Andrew: I don’t know about that – for Midnight to be a reaction to Absolute, it would presumably need to be sustainable in the long term. Nothing about the Midnight books makes me think they’re meant to last a year, let alone more than two.

  28. Michael says:

    @Diana- For what it’s worth, Hickman claims that he’s got 36 issues of Midnight X-Men plotted out,

  29. neutrino says:

    @Diana: Hickman says he has six six issue arcs planned.

  30. SanityOrMadness says:

    @Michael

    Betsy’s used psychic swords more than knives since the whole powerswap fiasco from Claremont’s “Revolution” run back in 2000. Hell, during that brief period between her being bodyswapped back and Krakoa, she used a TK sword *and shield* (HEMA style rather than katana, even though all her sword knowledge/experience was with Japanese swords). And then the Captain Britain thing was more sword stuff.

  31. SanityOrMadness says:

    [Also, looking at the main MXM #1 cover, the colouring makes it look like she’s “enhancing” a real sword, like Silver Samurai, rather than generating a whole psychic sword.]

  32. Diana says:

    @neutrino and @Michael: Hickman can say what he likes, between Krakoa and the Ultimate line I don’t think he’s got the stamina for 36 issues of anything.

  33. Salloh says:

    @Diana:

    “@neutrino and @Michael: Hickman can say what he likes, between Krakoa and the Ultimate line I don’t think he’s got the stamina for 36 issues of anything.”

    This, a bit? I understand there’s a lot of hype around Hickman, but I’m not completely clear on what large scale storyline he’s pushed through to completion since “Secret Wars” that makes the mystique hold – didn’t GODS get drastically reduced? Along with the entire Ultimate line, apparently?

    Do we want to be hyping the brilliant vampiric reimagining of the X-Men (oh god) when Hickman seems increasingly more important for the ideas he represents than for the actual stories he puts to paper?

    Mind you, I say this as someone who would have genuinely wished to see his vision of Krakoa come to tuition, if only for all the messy, tense and ugly aspects of it to be confronted rather glorified.

    But I’m not sure loudly announcing again just how differently he would have done it adds anything at all to the present state of things.

    Meanwhile, Kieron Fillen finishes actual scripts featuring characterization and everything.

    I don’t trust Marvel to have a lick of an idea of who and what it should be valuing, be it critically or commercially.

  34. Chris V says:

    I think there’s a half-way point to look at as far as Hickman. Was it a huge disappointment that Hickman left his Krakoa unfinished? Yes. However, the reason seems to involve editorial interference and how Hickman’s contract at Marvel works. Marvel was surprised at how high were the sales on Dawn of X and decided to extend the Krakoa experiment. Basically, Hickman said that Marvel wasn’t paying him to write a monthly title and decided to leave the book.

    GODS got cancelled almost immediately due to disappointing sales. I think it was a huge mistake to put out a $10 first issue on an unproven property. I’m guessing a majority of fans said they could wait for the Trade, which…whoops.

    The Ultimate line, we still don’t know what happened. It doesn’t seem to be Hickman’s fault. He fulfilled his commitment, and the Ultimate line was still selling very well, but Marvel decided to pull the plug anyway.

    On the other hand, Hickman can be blamed for Imperial. The series was a terrible mess. Hickman failed to garner the fan interest to maintain a cosmic line. However, Hickman only signed on to write the initial mini-series, so he did finish what he was contracted to write by Marvel.

    As far as Gillen, yes, he is a better writer than Hickman, but he has little interest in writing full-time for Marvel. He’d rather spend his time using the money he makes writing limited amounts of comics for Marvel creating his own titles at Image (or other indys), and I say that’s a better use of Gillen’s talents. He already charges more for his writing than the majority of comic writers (as does Hickman), so I wouldn’t say it’s a matter of Marvel not paying enough to keep Gillen. I think it’s simply that Marvel would never pay enough to make Gillen want to spend three years writing one title at Marvel.
    Now, Marvel not paying enough to keep Deniz Camp, and his jumping to DC is a different issue.

    As far as the Midnight Universe, it’s just too soon to say.

  35. Luis Dantas says:

    What I have seen of Hickman’s work strongly suggests that if there was unwise editorial interference into his Krakoa Era work, it was during the very early stages, by deciding to give him so much free reign that the franchise would have a hard time recovering a semblance of its regular status quo.

    It is a shame that G.O.D.S. wasn’t continued; IMO it is by a considerable margin his best work ever, not least because the toys are largely his to abuse and the canvas is so distanced from regular continuity. Secret Wars was grandiose, but to the best of my understanding it ended essentially by readers being informed that it was over somehow. I don’t know that there was a better way to end it.

    Krakoa Era could have been marvelous if it was acknowledged and promoted as a limited-time alternate continuity series. It never quite worked as part of the main continuity (too many absurd situations around the edges of what we saw on panel, too many overambitious plots with overly esoteric ideas), and deciding to keep it going double time was very much the wrong call, although I do not doubt that it resulted in good sales and increased prestige for Jordan White and his main writers in the short term.

    Hickman is great at presenting huge-concept storylines and Earth-shattering premises, but tends to write himself into corners that he can’t get out of. Instead of reigning him in and insisting on some sort of safeguards and guardrails, editorial got greedy and kept course for as long as it had any means to. The X-Men had to somehow transition from having a foretold grand cosmic destiny centuries ahead and being drunk of power and prepotence towards something recognizable and less Dune-like in a couple of very confused years. And they had to. Unless Marvel decided to bite the cannonball and reshape the whole line as… well, as they are doing with the symbiotes instead now.

    It is the same dilemma that doomed Mar-Vell’s book back in the 1970s and early 1980s. There is no way to meaningfully follow with the ongoing adventures of the champion who personally defeated Death itself and was forever changed while at it. You can’t very well turn the page towards something that is both meaningful and not some form of appendix to the resolved tale. Either you finish the tale, you reboot it in to some extent, or you gleefully go on to tell the stories that will never live up to that grand, cosmic destiny that was once destined to happen and now is not. The X-Men can’t very well be _both_ an emergent cosmic power, the spearhead of transforming Earth and Mars both into the embryo of a huge, cosmic, very inhuman galactic sentient being, and some form of fledging nation fighting against powerful, prejudiced enemies at every turn as well. Something has to give.

    The bottom line IMO is that it is a major challenge to find a talented writer that is both willing to commit to the sort of ambitious storyline that we have come to expect and willing to do that with characters that are not theirs to shape, control and potentially profit from. There is no compelling reason for a Kurt Busiek, Si Spurrier, Robert Kirkman or Kieron Gillen to opt out of their own, creator-owned projects to instead write X-Force or something.

    To the best of my knowledge, the only remaining superstar writers to remain writing for Marvel to any significant extent are Ryan North, Jed MacKay, Jonathan Hickman and Al Ewing.

    Ewing IMO has been both trying and being allowed to indulge into his worst excesses and the stories suffer for that.

    Hickman has been a superb acquisition for Marvel and I wish he and Marvel had decided to allow G.O.D.S. to find an audience, because that is his ideal Marvel niche. Anything closer to Earth’s everyday life ends up either being disrupted by the status quo or attempting to command the whole line instead. Imperial may be evidence that this model of storytelling can’t very well work anymore.

    As for Ryan North and Jed MacKay, IMO they both resemble Hickman at his best, and many of the same cautions are advised. One World Under Doom was ambitious and mostly well-handled, but there is only so much pressure to be put into the tires – and it was about a year long, followed from a slightly less overpowering storyline by MacKay (Blood Hunt), and is disputing real state with the symbiote storylines explosion as well as with the attempts at reestablishing Avengers and X-Men. It is a challenging situation that may all too easily get out of the rails.

    If recent news and speculation as I understand them are correct, Marvel has just announced that this is Marvel Unlimited’s last year, and will be moving to a local implementation of the Webtoon plataform real soon. Practically at the same time as it is moving to California. I think that it won’t be long until printed, paper comics will be stopped for good at Marvel. Webtoon is a much more directed plataform then Marvel Unlimited and Marvel may have decided (probably correctly) that it is a more cost-effective way of keeping the (now fully digital) comics working as the intellectual property farm and daytime care place that they have been for decades.

    Overall I not only expect that to happen, but I also think that it will be a boon for the general quality of stories. Crossovers and line-wide events will still happen, but will be much less confrontational and overpowering. Niche comics will resume being allowed to exist at Marvel.

    On the other hand, such a change won’t be great for distributors and specialty stores – but I figure that even them have largely refocused towards TPBs, collections and even non-comics merchandise anyway.

  36. Luis Dantas says:

    I also think that there is a lot of assumption going on about the Absolute line.

    I don’t understand why it keeps being compared to Ultimate 2.0 as opposed to Age of Apocalypse, which is a much more similar concept.

    I also think that much of its commercial success comes from the perception (that I believe and hope to be justified) that those books have a limited time to exist. If I am not mistaken, most were initially expected to last a year and have recently been extended towards a second full year. But some are wild departures from the confort zone and it will be difficult to keep them ongoing, while others are just not different enough to justify their continued publication alongside the perceived original articles. In a way they are the current form of living legacy of the Vertigo imprint, much as Young Animal and Black Label were once perceived to be.

    In that respect, I do recognize them as comparable to the Ultimate universes.

  37. Michael says:

    The sales figures for September are out. DNX 1 came in 4th. Infernal Hulk Vs. Wolverine 1 came in 19th. Deadpool 8 came in 23rd, X-Men 37 came in 32nd, Uncanny X-Men 35 came in 35th, Aliens Vs. X-Men 1 came in 42nd, and DNX 22 came in 44th.
    Deadpool did pretty well this month. I guess the crossover with the Punisher helped.
    In non X-books, Amazing Spider-Man 1000 came in 3rd after Batman of Two Worlds and Absolute Batman. But it was also the last week. I wonder how it will do after all the sales figures are totaled up.
    Avengers Armageddon 4 came in 13th. Issue 3 last month came in 12th. It did good but it doesn’t look like there was a bump from Colton being revealed as Miracleman.

  38. Diana says:

    @Michael: That last bit seems so self-evident I’m surprised Zdarsky and Yoshida-san ever expected otherwise. To the best of my knowledge, Marvel didn’t exactly make a mountain of money off their Miracleman reprints and the completion of The Silver Age.

  39. SanityOrMadness says:

    @Luis

    There has never been any indication that the Absolute line is intended as time-limited, and Snyder has talked about long-term plans a lot.

    [It’ll probably all come crashing down in the end like Ultimate 2000 did, but that took Jeph Loeb’s “gentle” touch, and it kept limping on for a while afterward until only Miles Morales was left.]

  40. Diana says:

    @SanityOrMadness: I’ll take that bet, and raise it – it’ll come crashing down the instant DC decides to do Absolute Crisis (because realistically, it’s only a matter of time).

  41. Chris V says:

    The Ultimate Universe was already starting to fail before Jeph Loeb because it no longer served its original purpose. It had its own convoluted continuity, new readers would be as hesitant to jump on to USM #100 as ASM #400, and the Ultimate line was running out of Earth-616 characters worth introducing in Ultimate form. Ultimate FF was cancelled. Kirkman’s Ultimate X-Men was considered a huge disappointment after Marvel was expecting to see fans react to it similar to the Millar days, Bendis had been writing Ultimate Spider-Man for over 100 issues (as you said, Miles Morales eventually gave Bendis some more momentum), and Millar didn’t want to work on Ultimates any longer. The line was already pretty much dead, and Marvel figured they could just throw the corpse to Loeb.

    I’m sure the same thing will eventually happen to the Absolute line and for the same reasons. These type of alternate universes catching on and being the biggest thing for a publisher have a limited shelf life.

  42. Mike Loughlin says:

    The Absolute line has been a success because..:

    The books are good.

    It’s well-done and people like it! It’s not rocket science: good books don’t always sell, but good books that are well-promoted stand a better chance.

    Yes, speculators chasing the first appearances of Absolute Bat-characters helps. Yes, the new-reader friendliness and limited scale of the universe helps. Yes, the “everything you know is wrong” approach helps. If the books weren’t good, the line would have folded in a year. See: Heroes Reborn.

    Bottom line: Dragotta, Sherman, Albequerque, Rodriguez, and others are very good artists. Snyder figured out how to run a comic on sheer audacity. Thompson put heart and intrigue into the story of a character most readers couldn’t care less about. Camp made a comic that prioritized vibes effectively while letting the artist cut loose. Etc.

    For the Midnight line, Marvel has emulated the hype and hired one known commodity (Hickman), one rising star (PKJ), some dependable hands (Percy, Shalvey) and a new comer who could turn into something (the artist on Midnight Spider-Man). It could grow. I don’t think it will reach Absolute heights, but they could have a decent hit on their hands…

    … if the books are good.

  43. I was more distracted by the new Spider-Man villain seemingly wearing Black Knight’s helmet for some reason.

  44. […] O’Brien hascapsule reviewsof Marvel Comics’DNX#2, X-Men #38, Fantastic Four #17, Uncanny X-Men #38, Tomb of Apocalypse #2, […]

  45. Michael says:

    @thekelvingreen- I think they were going for something out of Irish mythology and instead wound up looking like the Black Knight.

Leave a Reply