RSS Feed
Dec 4

Binary #3 annotations

Posted on Thursday, December 4, 2025 by Paul in Annotations

BINARY #3
Writer: Stephanie Phillips
Artist: Giada Belviso
Colourist: Rachelle Rosenberg
Letterer: Travis Lanham
Editor: Annalise Bissa

COVER: Um… well… it’s a woman running away from Phoenix. I assume she’s meant to be Carol Danvers, but she looks absolutely nothing like Carol Danvers beyond the fact that she’s white and blonde (as far as you can tell given that she’s coloured entirely in grey-blue, which means there’s a murky shape as the centre of focus). Her expression doesn’t seem scared, but more like she’s leading the Phoenix after her. I have no idea what it has to do with the story.

This is the final issue of Binary, which in turn was a continuation of Phoenix. That book isn’t returning in January, so the series truly does end here.

PAGES 1-7. Binary realises that she’s dealing with Madelyne Pryor, and Jean Grey manifests.

The basic plot so far is that Carol Danvers inherited the Phoenix Force after Jean Grey apparently burned herself out while containing the X-virus on Earth; that Carol has been using the Phoenix Force to protect her home town of Beverly, Massachusetts by shielding it from the X-virus in a psychic dome; that she started seeing Jean again last issue, since Jean and the Phoenix are one and the same as per Rise of the Powers of X; and that Madelyne Pryor has been scheming against Carol in an attempt to get the Phoenix powers for herself. (more…)

Dec 3

Amazing X-Men #3 annotations

Posted on Wednesday, December 3, 2025 by Paul in Annotations

AMAZING X-MEN vol 3 #3
“Philadelphia”
Writer: Jed MacKay
Artist: Mahmud Asrar
Colourist: Matthew Wilson
Letterer: Clayton Cowles
Editor: Tom Brevoort

COVER. The X-Men in the ruins of Philadelphia (rather worse than it actually looks in the stories), with a mural of Revelation.

Notionally this is the final issue of the miniseries, but in practice the story continues into X-Men: Age of Revelation – Finale. Counting the Overture issue as well, this is really more issue #4 of 5 than issue #3 of 3.

PAGES 1-4. Psylocke tells the X-Men what she learned from Bei.

Last issue, Cyclops won a duel against the Darkchild, who agreed to transport them from her territory in Providence to Revelation’s capital city of Philadelphia. Presumably that happened between issues and she’s dropped them off on the outskirts. Glob Herman seems genuinely surprised that they escaped Darkchild, which is clearly not a common experience – certainly the Age of Revelation X-Men seemed terrified of the place when they arrived there in issue #1.

All the material about Glob killing Topaz, and Psylocke being sent to kill Bei, comes from Overture. Psylocke’s account of what happened is correct as far as it goes. Interestingly, she comes across as much more sympathetic than the future X-Men – certainly than Glob Herman, who actively laughs about it, but all of the X-Men seem to have much more of a “this is war” attitude than Psylocke. Compared to the others, Schwarzchild seems the most reasonable, since at least he makes a fair point about Psylocke’s selectivity rather than just brushing Topaz’s death off.

(more…)

Dec 1

House to Astonish Presents: The Lightning Round Episode 28

Posted on Monday, December 1, 2025 by Al in Podcast

Paul and I hit a major milestone this episode, as we reach the end of the first run of the original Thunderbolts team, and cover issues 72-75. There’s fighting, arguments, and weird things exploding, and that’s just the behind the scenes escapades of Bill Jemas. Will all the TBolts survive? Will they all get off Counter-Earth? Will they all make it to the next volume of the book? Find out the answers to two of these questions right here, true believer!

Next up, it’s the Homies, so look out for a post on that in the next few days. And then… sigh… it’s Fightbolts.

The podcast is here, or available via the embedded player below. Let us know what you think in the comments, via email, or on Bluesky!

Nov 30

Daredevil Villains #64: Lord Dark Wind

Posted on Sunday, November 30, 2025 by Paul in Daredevil

DAREDEVIL #196-199 (July to October 1983)
“Enemies” / “Journey” / “Touch of a Stranger” / “Daughter of a Dark Wind”
Writer: Denny O’Neil
Pencillers: Klaus Janson (#196-197), Larry Hama (breakdowns on #196 and “art assist” on #197) & William Johnson (#197-199)
Inkers: Klaus Janson (#196-197), Mike Mignola (#197) & Danny Bulanadi (#198-199)
Colourists: Christie Scheele (#196-197), Glynis Wein (#198) & Bob Sharen (#199)
Letterer: Joe Rosen
Editor: Linda Grant

We’ve been through a string of fill-ins, but with issue #200 around the corner, it’s time for an actual storyline, and for Denny O’Neil’s run to get into full swing.

The change of creative team is completed here, with Klaus Janson leaving the book after the opening scene of issue #196. His replacement is William Johnson, who’ll be with us for less than a year. Compared to the artists who came before and after him, Johnson isn’t particularly well known. His only previous work for Marvel had been the final four issues of Master of Kung Fu, and he moved over to Daredevil when that book was cancelled.

His opening splash page in issue #197 is frankly not great, but once he settles in, his art is perfectly good – if rather conservative compared to what’s come before. Reportedly, he was taken off the book because he couldn’t handle a monthly schedule. This seems highly plausible, since he drew only eight out of eleven issues during his run, and as far as I can tell, he never worked as a regular penciller on an ongoing title again. He did some scattered fill-in work on Marvel’s licensed books over the next few years before apparently dropping out of the industry.

(more…)

Nov 29

Charts – 28 November 2025

Posted on Saturday, November 29, 2025 by Paul in Music

Okay, well, at least we’re less than a month out from Christmas. I guess.

1. Taylor Swift – “The Fate of Ophelia”

Six weeks at number 1, and the same deal as last week: it’s past its peak, and it’s only number 1 Olivia Dean’s “Man I Need” has been out long enough to be downweighted under the ACR rule. It’s basically marking time until the Christmas records come along to replace it.

14. Cynthia Erivo & Ariana Grande – “For Good”
17. Cynthia Erivo – “No Good Deed”
29. Cynthia Erivo & Jonathan Bailey – “As Long As You’re Mine”

(more…)

Nov 28

The X-Axis – 24 November 2025

Posted on Friday, November 28, 2025 by Paul in x-axis

X-MEN: AGE OF REVELATION INFINITY COMIC #4. By Tim Seeley, Phillip Sevy, Michael Bartolo & Clayton Cowles. Oh boy. So this one went down well. It’s the first part of a Magik storyline filling her “Age of Revelation” back story. We already established, back in Age of Revelation #0, that Magik had died on the raid that freed Fabian Cortez from SHIELD custody, and that she returned as the Darkchild to rule Providence. Most of this issue consists of the raid itself, which is a bit underwhelming – she gets carried away, kills Maria Hill, and then gets gunned down by Nick Fury. It’s not especially creative. Anyway, the big idea is that the Bloodstones that Belasco conjured from Magik’s soul during her childhood mean that her soul passes to his control on death, with him apparently restored as the ruler of Limbo. That seems like something we might be wanting to address in the present day. The issue then cuts to a rather confusing segment of Darkchild (apparently separate from Magik) as S’ym’s slave, which doesn’t make a whole lot of sense to me. I guess it’s a jump forward in time? I think?

It’s not an especially good issue, but many of the complaints seem to be reading in things that aren’t there, or seizing on subtext that’s been part of Magik’s back story for forty years. But you can give Illyana a depressing ending in an alternate future timeline – in the long run it becomes something that she’s motivated to avoid when Cyclops reports back on it. Mind you, if you’re going to give female characters sexualised costumes, you can’t really complain when people read the humiliation sequence with S’ym and take you at face value. But this is more heavy-handed than anything else, certainly in a context where we already know that the story is going to end with Darkchild reclaiming Limbo. Having said that, I’m not really very interested in reading a repeat of Magik’s back story where the Darkchild persona comes out on top, which seems to be where we’re going here. That just feels repetitive, and doesn’t really fit with what’s been done with Darkchild in Magik lately.

(more…)

Nov 27

Expatriate X-Men #2 annotations

Posted on Thursday, November 27, 2025 by Paul in Annotations

EXPATRIATE X-MEN #2
Writer: Eve L Ewing
Artist: Francesco Mortarino
Colourist: Raúl Angulo
Letterer: Ariana Maher
Editor: Tom Brevoort

COVER: Rift, Melée, Bronze and Ms Marvel in the crosshairs of… something.

PAGES 1-5. Bronze brings Colossus his medication.

Bronze. She hasn’t met Colossus yet in the present day timeline, but in this timeline she calls him “Unc” (and he calls her “Tristachka”). She’s clearly trying to keep up good spirits when talking to Colossus, although talking about the loss of Kitty Pryde (see below) does bring tears to her eyes. She claims that Kitty would want them to “live”.

Colossus. He was on the cover of the previous issue, but didn’t actually appear, so this is the first time we’ve actually seen him in the “Age of Revelation” timeline. He has a cabin on the Dragonfly and doesn’t look to be in great health. His left arm has been replaced with a crude cyborg one, and much fo the left side of his body seems damaged (it’s hard to tell whether it’s meant to represent rust, or acid burns, or what). He seems to get through pills at quite a rate – Bronze gives him four to take in one go, which nearly exhausts the supply. He has regular nightmares about the missing Kitty Pryde.

(more…)

Nov 26

Housekeeping

Posted on Wednesday, November 26, 2025 by Paul in Uncategorized

Annotations will be up tomorrow.

Nov 23

Charts – 21 November 2025

Posted on Sunday, November 23, 2025 by Paul in Music

Oh god, already? Really?

1. Taylor Swift – “The Fate of Ophelia” 

Five weeks total. Its streams are down, and it’s not that far ahead of “Golden” at number 2 (about 6%), but the bigger point is that it’s now number 1 with an asterisk – if we didn’t have the downweighting rule, this week’s number one would be “Man I Need” by Olivia Dean, and by a comfortable margin at that.

19. Wham! – “Last Christmas”

What the hell is wrong with you people? This is the chart measuring the period 14-20 November. That’s more than a month before Christmas. And yet even with permanent downweighting against it, “Last Christmas” is already at number 19. God help us.

(more…)

Nov 22

The X-Axis – w/c 18 November 2025

Posted on Saturday, November 22, 2025 by Paul in x-axis

X-MEN: AGE OF REVELATION INFINITY COMIC #3. By Tim Seeley, Phillip Sevy, Michael Bartolo & Clayton Cowles. Oh, it’s a three-parter. I figured we’d be spending longer with early-AoR Revelation. Instead, this issue switches to Revelation as its narrator. Tim Seeley does have an interesting angle on how Revelation feels about Cable: he doesn’t really know the guy, precisely because he died before the New Mutants met Cable, and maybe Cable is the hardening mentor that he missed out on. But the plot boils down to Revelation summarily defeating the villain, and then getting rid of Cable too. This might be heading towards Cable being the source of the techno-organics we’ve seen sporadically in “Age of Revelation”, and perhaps it does make sense in the wider scheme of things that Revelation just swans into the story and ends it… but it reads a little oddly.

UNBREAKABLE X-MEN #2. (Annotations here.) I’m not sure this story has very much to do with “Age of Revelation” at all, but the flipside is that it has quite a lot to do with Uncanny X-Men, by picking up the Dark Artery/Shuvahrak storyline in the near future. Shuvahrak is a weird character, with Gail Simone’s stories seeming to be intentionally vague about how she became transformed and how she came to turn against mutants in general. But it kind of works; the story wants her to be a sort of looming, ungraspable presence who’s been changed from a conventional character into a kind of Cthulhuesque monster of unavenged sins, and spelling her out too directly would point away from that. The downside is to leave the stakes a little bit obscure, but I think it’s a more interesting story for leaning into the mood. CF Villa’s art really sells Shuvahrak’s demonic angle too, even while it gives us the clearest view of her that we’ve had to date. The rest of the issue mostly consists of gathering the Outliers for a last stand, with a few more hints of things to come – though the clash with the way Deathdream was written in Amazing X-Men is really, really hard to interpret as anything other than an error. I’m still not sure what Spider-Girl is doing in this book – maybe she’s showing up in Uncanny soon, maybe it’s just a vague gesture at the wider Marvel Universe for the sake of the event.

(more…)